Who’s Hot? ID’s ‘Pulp Faction’ and Other Unscripted US Network Winners, 1Q 2014 vs 1Q 2013

The tide of Unscripted US networks keeps on rising:

But the boats rise and fall unevenly:

  • Following is our snapshot of year-to-year changes in viewing of unscripted channels.
  • First: The Top 12 Winners in our sample (%)

1QWinners14

METHODOLOGY

Our selection includes

  • Channels that are dedicated to non-scripted, for example Nat Geo Wild (up 16%).
  • Others like MTV (up 2%) include a significant offer of Scripted in their mix.

Quantity Not Quality

  • Advertiser-supported channels sell media based on their target demos.
  • And networks rate their performance quarter-to-quarter rather than year-to-year.
  • Nevertheless, our measure of the quarterly average prime time adult audience is a useful tool for gauging the relative scale of viewing and year-to-year trends.

 

A Selection of U.S. Factual Channels
Average Quarterly Prime Time Audience
1Q 2014 vs 1Q 2013
(’000)
1Q ’14 1Q ’13 +/-
Rating AA (000) AA (000) (000)
ID 0.9            772            598 174 29%
TLC 1.0            954            791 163 21%
OWN 0.5            433            285 148 52%
SPIKE 0.8            755            626 129 21%
WETV 0.4            359            244 115 47%
VH1 0.6            529            430 99 23%
DISCOVERY 1.1         1,093         1,014 79 8%
CMT 0.3            301            236 65 28%
BRAVO 1.0            939            875 64 7%
H2 0.5            352            306 46 15%
BET 0.7            630            590 40 7%
VELOCITY 0.2            135               97 38 39%
DIY 0.3            161            128 33 26%
IFC 0.2            151            121 30 25%
NAT GEO WILD 0.4            200            173 27 16%
CNBC 0.2            205            180 25 14%
E! 0.5            482            464 18 4%
BBC America 0.2            189            176 13 7%
MTV 0.8            730            717 13 2%
FIT & HEALTH 0.2            100              88 12 14%
OVATION 0.1              56              46 10 22%
TRAVEL 0.4            396            386 10 3%
WEATHER 0.2            200            195 5 3%

Source:  Nielsen Media Research

WHAT CAUGHT MY EYE?

ID Pickpockets Crime

Discovery’s ID channel is again on fire (up 29%) by super-serving the audience for Crime.

  • I worked at CBS when Murder She Wrote was the #1 hit on US network television. So it’s been amazing to see ID dominate the unscripted Crime genre without a serious challenge.
  • True Crime appeals to Women, but doesn’t send men out to the toolshed.
  • Our measure is of prime time. ID also made big gains during Daytime as Female viewers looked for an alternative to Soaps.

ID works the Titles Process harder than any other network:

  • ID’s titles, like Wives With Knives, are hands down the Best in Show.
  • In the competitive free-for-all of the EPG universe, as in book publishing, the title is as important as the content.

Discovery Rising?

Of my Top 12 list of networks measured by audience gains (‘000), #1-3 are in the Discovery camp.

  • They are ID, TLC and OWN.
  • TLC is up (21%), perhaps by pulling back from its most extreme family characters.
  • Discovery is #7 on my list, and is making solid gains, despite the lack of a big hit.
  • Velocity is up (39%) as is Fit & Health (14%), though on tiny audiences.
  • Velocity super-serves the car lover niche with vehicle beauty shows, auto makeovers and the like. But no auto sports.

The Top 12 (‘000)

Here are the Top 12 winners in our sample (‘000).

1QWinners14'000

Takeaways

Where’s that Buzzy Thing?

  • The buzz is drifting away from network series towards online video and social media.
  • This is particularly so for younger viewers who set the trends in the popular culture.
  • It’s just getting harder and harder for a hit series, much less a channel, to break through the clutter of networks, platforms and shows.
  • It seems like another era when a single series, Queer Eye, transformed Bravo from an Arts channel into a pop culture powerhouse.

Super-serving Niches!

  • A related Takeaway is that the strategic advantage is flowing away from all those barely distinguishable, hit-driven channels.
  • The winners are networks like ID and Velocity that are clearly branded and that methodically super-serve their niche audiences.
  • More on this in future posts.

Titles Matter!

  • ID proves that show titles matter more than ever!

More Reading

  • Don’t miss Dana Bramble’s analysis of what’s driving OWN, WEtv and other channels in her excellent coverage of 4Q 2013.
  • Congrats to Dana who graduated this weekend from American U.
  • Featured Image: From Sarah Weinman’s Domestic Suspense website. Highly recommended!
  • And don’t miss historian Madeleine Hamilton’s Our Girls: Aussie Pinups of the 40’s and 50’s
  • Here’s my super-talented niece at her book launch in Melbourne:

Madeleine

 

The Rise & Rise Leftfield Entertainment

From a $20,000 Stake t0 a $450 Million Valuation

 

Pawn Stars was the breakout hit for Leftfield Pictures:

  • In 2007, Leftfield produced 1 television hour.
  • In 2013: more than 336!
  • Pawn Stars ranked #1 in 2012 among all U.S. cable non-fiction series.
  • Pawn Stars is being launched by A+E Networks in the UK and Australia.

Our interview-based Case Study analyzes the ‘secret sauce’ behind Leftfield’s trajectory from a single hit producer to its sale to ITV Studios at a valuation of $450 million.

Contents
(45 pages / charts / links to sizzle tapes)

  • Introduction
  • Before Leftfield: Gaining Production Experience
  • Pawn Stars: Concept, Talent, Sizzle Tape, Pitch, Green Light, HIT!
  • After Pawn Stars: Corporate Structure, Renewals, Pitches, more Green Lights. What Next?
  • Leftfield Pictures 2007-2013. Snapshot: Episodes, Hours, Networks
  • Leftfield goes International
  • The acquisitions of Sirens Media creates Leftfield Entertainment
  • Leftfield Puts Casting Under a Microscope
  • Pawn Stars, The Inside Story: How to Create & Sustain a Hit Reality Series (Panel Videos)
  • Ten Negotiation Secrets of the Pawn Stars
  • Attachments and Links (includes a link to the Pawn Stars sizzle tape)

Order here and download now: $49:95

Pawn-Stars-2013-Chart_Oct30